Aging With Every Heartbeat

15/12/2024

Aging With Every Heartbeat

aka

Why Do Chameleons Get Old in Captivity While They Are Still Young


Chameleons are in general still considered a short living reptiles. It is true for the wild, where many middle-sized species do not live more than 2-4 seasons die to harsh climatic conditions in some seasons or predatory or parasitic pressure. In captivity, we can eliminate these factors and give them great conditions to live long. And, reports of responsible keepers prove, it is possible. The Yemen Chameleon has been proven to have a longevity record of 16years, Panther Chameleon 12, Jackson's Chameleon 14, Parson's Chameleon 23… So far the absolute records. The reality is rather frustrating. The average life span of the Yemen Chameleon in human care is somewhere between 3-6 years, Panthers even less.

Let us explain why is that. The reality is rather complex and the explanation, however simple it will reveal, it is to be put together like a puzzle from several elements:

  1. Heart rate in chameleons and its dependence from environmental factors
  2. Heart rate in Chamaeleo calyptratus and its dependence from temperature
  3. Climatic condition of the home countries misunderstood
  4. Climatic cycles ignored or manipulated in captivity
  5. Longevity records versus average longevity
  6. Heartbeats as age indicator

Puzzle 1:

Heart rate in chameleons and its dependence from environmental factors


Heart rate is the frequency of the heartbeat measured by the number of contractions of the heart per minute.

The heart rate of reptiles, including chameleons, is significantly influenced by temperature due to their ectothermic (or cold-blooded) nature. In ectothermic animals, physiological processes, including heart rate, are largely dependent on external environmental temperatures. Here are some key points regarding the relationship between temperature and heart rate in chameleons and other reptiles:

1. Ectothermic Regulation: Reptiles do not internally regulate their body temperature; instead, their body temperature fluctuates with the ambient temperature. As the temperature increases, metabolic processes—such as heart activity—tend to speed up.

2. Temperature Coefficient (Q10): The heart rate of reptiles often exhibits a Q10 value of approximately 2 to 3, meaning that for every 10°C increase in temperature, the heart rate can approximately double or triple. This is due to the direct influence of temperature on enzymatic activity and electrical impulses in the heart.

3.Behavioral Thermoregulation: Chameleons use behavioral adaptations to maintain an optimal body temperature. They bask in sunlight to warm up or seek shade to cool down, which directly affects their heart rate. Warmer temperatures lead to increased heart rates that facilitate faster movement, digestion, and hormonal processes.

4. Physiological Response: At higher temperatures, chameleons exhibit increased cardiac output and heart rate, which enhances blood flow and oxygen delivery to the body. Conversely, at lower temperatures, their heart rate decreases, leading to reduced metabolic activity, which is essential for survival in cooler environments.

5. Stress and Thermal Limits: Extreme temperatures on either end can lead to stress or even fatal outcomes for chameleons and other reptiles. At very high temperatures, although heart rates may increase, it can lead to issues such as thermal stress, dehydration, or cardiac failure.

6. Studies and Observations: Research has shown that specific heart rates can be measured under controlled temperature conditions, providing insights into the adaptability and thermal tolerance of chameleons. For instance, a common chameleon species may demonstrate heart rates ranging from approximately 30 beats per minute at low temperatures to over 100 beats per minute at optimal basking temperatures.

Chameleons, like other reptiles, demonstrate a clear dependence of heart rate on ambient temperature, showcasing the importance of environmental conditions on their physiological functions. Understanding these relationships is vital for their care in captivity and for insights into their ecological adaptations.


Puzzle 3:

Climatic condition of the home countries misunderstood

Despite the accessibility and user-friendly nature of climatological websites, the general understanding of the climates in the native regions of chameleons is significantly flawed and misunderstood. Many people erroneously perceive chameleons as creatures inhabiting much warmer and more humid environments than is actually the case. A prime example of this misconception is the Yemen chameleon, often inaccurately described as a desert species living in lowland areas. In truth, this chameleon species resides at much higher altitudes, often surpassing that of many so-called montane species in Africa, thriving in biotopes that are considerably cooler than most people realize. Let us summarize the climate of the region, inhabited by the Yemen chameleon:

Temperatures

The average yearly ambient temperature in Ibb, Yemen, typically ranges between 15°C and 25°C (59°F to 77°F). Given its elevation (approximately 2,200 meters or 7,200 feet above sea level), Ibb enjoys a milder climate compared to other regions in Yemen, which often experience hotter temperatures. Annual Average: About 19°C (66°F). Rainfall: Ibb experiences a significant amount of rainfall, particularly from April to October, contributing to its lush landscapes.

The figure below shows you a compact characterization of the entire year of hourly average temperatures. The horizontal axis is the day of the year, the vertical axis is the hour of the day, and the color is the average temperature for that hour and day.

Clouds

In Ibb, the average percentage of the sky covered by clouds experiences extreme seasonal variation over the course of the year. The clearer part of the year in Ibb begins around September 19 and lasts for 7.2 months, ending around April 27. The clearest month of the year in Ibb is November, during which on average the sky is clear, mostly clear, or partly cloudy 77% of the time. The cloudier part of the year begins around April 27 and lasts for 4.8 months, ending around September 19. The cloudiest month of the year in Ibb is July, during which on average the sky is overcast or mostly cloudy 73% of the time.

Rainfall

To show variation within the months and not just the monthly totals, we show the rainfall accumulated over a sliding 31-day period centered around each day of the year. Ibb experiences some seasonal variation in monthly rainfall.  The rainy period of the year lasts for 6.4 months, from March 28 to October 10, with a sliding 31-day rainfall of at least 0.5 inches. The month with the most rain in Ibb is August, with an average rainfall of 1.5 inches. The rainless period of the year lasts for 5.6 months, from October 10 to March 28. The month with the least rain in Ibb is December, with an average rainfall of 0.2 inches

Puzzle 2:

Heart rate in Chamaeleo calyptratus and its dependence from temperature


The heart rate of chameleons, like many reptiles, varies significantly with temperature due to their ectothermic physiology. The specific heart rates can depend on the species of chameleon and individual health, altitude and other factors, here The Yemen Chameleon showed general overview of heart rates at various temperatures as follows (measured at 400m a.s.l) for 25 individuals (9 males, 16 females, all between 2and 5 years age).

While they may be able to sustain increased heart rates, prolonged exposure to high temperatures can lead to thermal stress and may be dangerous.

Note:

Heart rates can also be influenced by factors such as health status, hydration, and time of day (diurnal vs. nocturnal activity).

Measuring heart rates in a controlled environment is essential for accurate readings, as stress from handling or environmental changes can also affect heart rates.


Puzzle 6:

Heartbeats as age indicator

The life of reptiles, as well as other animals, can be estimated in heartbeats. This concept is based on the understanding that different species have differing heart rates, and these heart rates can provide a rough approximation of the length of an animal's life.

The Concept:

1. Heart Rate: The average heart rate in reptiles varies widely depending on the species, temperature, and activity level, but it typically ranges from 10 to 100 beats per minute (bpm) in many reptiles.

2. Lifespan: Most reptiles have relatively long lifespans compared to smaller animals. For example, many turtles can live for over 50 years, some species of iguanas can live for 20-30 years, and larger reptiles like crocodiles can live for several decades.

3. Heartbeat Calculation: To estimate the total number of heartbeats over a reptile's life, you can multiply the average heart rate by the number of minutes in an hour, by the number of hours in a day, and finally by the number of years the reptile is expected to live.

Formula:

Total Heartbeats = Heart Rate (bpm) * 60 * 24 *365 * Lifespan (years)

Additional Considerations:

  • Variability: Different species have vastly different metabolic rates, which can affect heart rate. For example, a chameleon may have a different average heart rate compared to a tortoise, impacting the longevity calculation based on heartbeats.

  • Impact of Temperature: Since reptiles are ectothermic (cold-blooded), their heart rates can change with environmental temperatures. Warmer temperatures typically increase heart rates, while cooler temperatures lower them.

  • Lifespan Impact: Generally, larger reptiles with slower metabolisms (such as tortoises) may have fewer heartbeats in their lifetimes compared to smaller, faster-growing reptiles (like some lizards).

While calculating the life of reptiles in heartbeats can provide an interesting perspective on their lifespan and physiology, it's important to remember that this is a rough estimation. Many factors influence heart rate and lifespan in reptiles, so while such calculations can be informative, they should be considered within the broader context of the species' biology and environment.


Puzzle 5:

Longevity records versus average longevity

The average lifespan of lizards varies widely depending on the species, and their maximum longevity records also differ significantly. Here's a rough estimation of average lifespans and maximum longevity records for some common lizard species, followed by the percentages of average lifespan relative to maximum longevity.

For lizards, the percentage of average lifespan compared to maximum longevity often falls between 67% to 80% (average 75%) depending on the species. This reflects a relatively high ratio of average lifespan to maximum longevity among lizards.


Puzzle 4:

Climatic cycles ignored or manipulated in captivity

Chameleons in captivity are often kept at temperatures that are far too high. With nearly four decades of experience, I have dedicated myself to educating the herpetocultural community about the proper care parameters for these remarkable reptiles, consistently stressing the importance of avoiding overheating. Despite publishing numerous articles on this critical issue, my stance has sometimes made me unpopular in certain circles, as some individuals prefer to dismiss conflicting opinions rather than adjust their care practices.

Many enthusiasts are blinded by their desire to keep these extraordinary animals, overlooking the fact that their home environments do not necessarily provide suitable conditions. They are often reluctant to invest in relatively costly measures to lower temperatures, mistakenly believing that chameleons will simply adapt and thrive. This is a misconception. I frequently engage in discussions with individuals who argue that these reptiles come from warm climates and can tolerate high temperatures in captivity. Such reasoning is fundamentally misguided; adaptation is not an instantaneous process, and the physiological needs of animals that have evolved over millions of years cannot be altered simply because we wish for it within a few days or months.

I am genuinely frustrated and disheartened by this issue, especially in an era when access to information is more abundant than ever. Obtaining detailed climate data about Yemen, particularly in regions central to the habitat of Yemen's chameleons, takes only seconds. Nonetheless, widespread ignorance regarding their proper care persists, resulting in the prevalence of incorrect conditions for these animals. The consequences are severe: discomfort, distress, abnormal physiological responses, altered behavior, and an inability to reproduce or sleep. Ultimately, this leads to the suffering and premature death of these creatures. This is a harsh reality we must confront.

In numerical terms, using the Yemen chameleon as an example, we observe the following temperature ranges:

Nighttime temperatures can drop to around **40°F (approximately 4°C) and typically do not exceed 60°F (about 16°C).

Daytime temperatures generally do not rise above 85°F (approximately 29°C), usually remaining around 75°F (approximately 24°C) and often dropping to about 65°F (approximately 18°C).

In contrast, most apartments in Europe and the United States maintain temperatures that are comfortable for humans, typically around 75°F (approximately 24°C) both day and night. This is nearly 10°F (about 5.5°C) higher than the highest ever nighttime temperatures that Yemen chameleons experience in the wild.

Additionally, chameleons are often mistakenly believed to require extensive basking. In practice, basking temperatures are frequently set above 85°F (approximately 29°C) and can easily reach 100°F (approximately 38°C) due to the proximity of heat sources. 

Furthermore, basking temperatures are typically measured at the basking branch, which is often situated almost half a foot below the actual basking area on the head and back of the big Yemen chameleon.

This discrepancy creates a significant difference that cannot be tolerated by the animals, leading to various negative and potentially lethal consequences.


Final calculation and the bitter truth

Let's break down the calculations step by step with the given data:

DATA:

1. Average Yearly Temperature for Yemen Chameleon in the Wild: 19°C

2. Average Heart Rate at 19°C: 22 bpm

3. Average Yearly Temperature for Yemen Chameleons in Captivity: 30°C

4. Average Heart Rate at 30°C: 71 bpm**


Step 1: Calculate How Many Times the Heart Rate is Faster

To find out how many times the heart rate increases from wild to captivity, we can use the formula:

Heart Rate Ratio = Heart Rate in Captivity / Heart Rate in the Wild = 71 / 22 = 3.23


Step 2: Longevity of Yemen Chameleons in Captivity

Record Longevity: 16 years

Adjusted Longevity Considering 75% Reduction:

16 * 0.75 = 12 years


Step 3: Divide Adjusted Longevity by Heart Rate Ratio

Now, to find the theoretical average life span divided by the heart rate ratio calculated earlier:
 12years  /  3.23 = 3.71years


Conclusion: 

1. The heart rate in captivity is approximately 3.23 times faster than in the wild.

2. If we take the adjusted lifespan to be around 12 years, dividing that by the heart rate ratio gives us a theoretical average lifespan of about 3.71 years when adjusted for the increased heart rate due to higher temperatures.

This highlights the significant physiological stress that captive conditions may impose on chameleons compared to their natural habitat. And thisnis in full accordance with the longevity expectations if the Yemen Chamrleon in layman ignorant care in captivity.

Or in. other words but with same numbers: in 12 years, the heart of  a wild Yemen chameleon (at a erahe temperature 19°C / 66°F) will beat 138 758 400 times [22bpm * (12yrs* 365 days * 24hours * 60) minutes]. We then easily calculate in how much time the heart beats the same ammount of beats at rhe temperature of 30°C / 86°F at the heart beat rate 71 bpm. It will take only about 2 million minutes, means 3,71 years.

This comparison highlights how the chameleon's heart can remain functional for the same total number of heartbeats at lower temperatures in the wild over a longer lifespan of 12 years or at higher average temperatures in captivity in just 3.71 years. Such differences in environmental conditions and heart rate emphasize the physiological stress these animals may experience in captivity compared to their natural habitats. Moreover, some temperatures lead to death immediately or in a shorter period of time not by higher heart beat but by the collapse of rhe whole homeostasis of the organism.

 This highlights the significant physiological stress that captive conditions may impose on chameleons compared to their natural habitat. And thisnis in full accordance with the longevity expectations if the Yemen Chamrleon in layman ignorant care in captivity.


Chameleons die youg while they age at faster rate and beat same ammount of heartbrats due to human unethical overheating them! 

Author: Petr Nečas
My projects:   ARCHAIUS   │   CHAMELEONS.INFO